The strongest study so far: a national lottery trial
Lillard and colleagues, writing in PNAS (published 20 October 2025), followed 588 children who entered admission lotteries at age 3 at 24 oversubscribed public Montessori schools across the US. 242 were offered a seat; 346 were not. Because seats were assigned by lottery, the two groups were comparable at the start.
- Found: no notable differences at the end of the two preschool years. At the end of kindergarten, the group offered Montessori scored significantly higher on reading, short-term memory, theory of mind (understanding others' thoughts) and executive function. Effect sizes were above a fifth of a standard deviation. Children also did somewhat better in math.
- Not found: no significant differences in vocabulary, social problem-solving or a persistence task; the last two leaned slightly toward the comparison group.
- Limits the authors list: only 20% of lottery entrants consented, more in the Montessori group (31%) than the comparison group (17%); 32% and 42% were missing kindergarten tests; the schools were popular ones, not a random sample; and results stop at kindergarten.
The federal What Works Clearinghouse reviewed it in January 2026 and rated it as meeting its standards with reservations, because of high attrition.
Earlier studies and the meta-analysis
- Two magnet schools, 2017. A smaller lottery study (Frontiers in Psychology) followed 141 children at two public Montessori magnet schools in a high-poverty US city from age 3 to 6. Montessori children did better over time on academic achievement, social understanding and mastery orientation, and the gap between lower and higher income children was smaller.
- Meta-analysis, 2023. Randolph and colleagues (Campbell Systematic Reviews) pooled 32 studies that met their quality bar. Montessori outperformed traditional education on average: about 0.24 standard deviations across academic outcomes and 0.33 across nonacademic ones such as executive function. Effects were larger for randomized studies, preschool and elementary, and private schools. They noted possible publication bias but found the result held in a sensitivity check.
One fair caution: Angeline Lillard, a long-time Montessori researcher, is an author on all three papers. That does not make them wrong, but more independent replication would help.
What the evidence does not tell you
- Whether one particular school near you is good. Implementation varies, and the PNAS authors note that implementation predicts outcomes.
- Whether gains last past kindergarten for the children in the national study; that follow-up has not been published.
- Whether Montessori beats an excellent play-based program for your child. Studies compare Montessori with whatever else children attended.
- Anything about Montessori-branded toys or home setups. The research is about classrooms with trained teachers.
What it costs, and what drives the price
There is no reliable national figure for Montessori tuition, and prices vary widely by city and program. For context, Child Care Aware of America reports a 2024 national average price of child care of $13,128 a year across care types, and notes that state and local prices differ a lot. Public Montessori is tuition-free for families: the National Center for Montessori in the Public Sector counts 596 public Montessori schools and programs in 43 states and Washington, DC (June 2026), though access for 3-year-olds depends on your district. Private tuition is driven by:
- Full day versus half day, and extended care
- Age group: infant and toddler programs usually cost more because ratios are smaller
- Teacher training and pay, and accreditation fees
- Local rent and the cost of materials
In the national study, three years of public Montessori cost districts $13,127 less per child than traditional programs, mostly because of higher child-to-teacher ratios at ages 3 and 4. That is a cost to districts, not a tuition price.
How to decide for your family
Ask three questions. Is there a public Montessori option near you? Does this specific school have trained Montessori teachers, mixed ages and a long morning work period? And can you afford it without strain for the full three-year cycle, since the national study measured children who started at age 3? If the answer to the last one is no, a warm, well-run local preschool plus a calm, independent home life is a sound choice. See Montessori at home without expensive materials.
Side by side
| Study | Who was studied | What it found | Main limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lillard et al., PNAS, 2025 | 588 children in lotteries at 24 public Montessori schools, age 3 to end of kindergarten | Higher reading, short-term memory, theory of mind and executive function at end of kindergarten | 20% consent; missing data; popular schools only; no results past kindergarten |
| What Works Clearinghouse review, 2026 | The same PNAS study | Meets WWC standards with reservations; at least one significant positive finding | Single-study review; high attrition |
| Lillard et al., Frontiers in Psychology, 2017 | 141 children at two public magnet schools in one high-poverty city | Better academic achievement, social understanding and mastery orientation by age 6 | Two schools, one city, small sample |
| Randolph et al., Campbell Systematic Reviews, 2023 | 32 studies with baseline equivalence, preschool to high school | Positive average effects, academic 0.24 and nonacademic 0.33 standard deviations | Studies vary in quality; possible publication bias; search ended February 2020 |
| Child Care Aware of America, 2024 | National child care prices, all care types | Average price of child care $13,128 a year | Not Montessori-specific; varies widely by state |
| NCMPS Montessori Census, 2026 | US public Montessori schools | 596 public schools and programs in 43 states and DC, tuition-free | Seats for 3-year-olds vary by district |
Example: a one-page decision sheet
For example, imagine two parents comparing a private Montessori school and a local play-based preschool. They fill in one line each:
- Teacher training: Montessori lead teacher holds a Montessori diploma for ages 3 to 6. Play-based lead teacher has an early childhood degree.
- Morning observed: Montessori, children worked calmly for a long block. Play-based, warm, busy, lots of pretend play.
- Cost for three years: written from each school's fee sheet, including extended care.
- Our child on the visit: stayed close to us at the first, joined a block tower at the second.
- Decision rule: if both are good, choose the one we can afford for the full three years without stress.
Who this is not for
- This page summarizes research; it cannot predict how one child will do in one school.
- It does not give Montessori tuition figures, because no reliable national source exists; call local schools for their current prices.
- If you are weighing a school because of a developmental concern, start with your pediatrician; no preschool model replaces an evaluation.
Where Zeys Montessori fits
ONE-TO-ONE GUIDANCE
Parent guidance with Zeynep
Talk through your own child's situation with an Early Childhood Montessori teacher, by email first.
Parent guidance, educator workshops and school consulting are arranged by email; prices are not published, ask for current availability.
Email hello@zeysmontessori.comQuestions people ask
Is Montessori evidence based?
Yes, with limits: a 2025 national lottery study and a 2023 meta-analysis both found positive effects. The evidence is strongest for public preschool programs measured through kindergarten, and it cannot vouch for every school using the name.
Do the benefits of Montessori last?
We do not know yet for the national study, because results so far stop at the end of kindergarten. The 2023 meta-analysis included some studies of older students and found positive average effects, but long-term follow-up of the same children is still needed.
Is private Montessori better than public Montessori?
The 2023 meta-analysis found larger average effects in private Montessori studies, but that does not mean any private school beats any public one. Families who choose private schools may differ in other ways, so judge each school on its own.
Is Montessori worth it if we can only afford one year?
It can still be a good year, but the studies measured children who began at age 3 and stayed through a multi-year cycle. If one year strains your budget, a good local preschool is a reasonable choice.
Why is Montessori so expensive?
Private Montessori prices reflect trained teachers, specialized materials, rent and program length, and infant and toddler rooms cost more because each adult cares for fewer children. Public Montessori schools are tuition-free, so check your district first.
Does it matter if a school is accredited?
Accreditation is one useful signal, because the name Montessori is not trademarked and any school can use it. Also ask about teacher training, mixed ages and the length of the morning work period, and observe a class.
Sources
- Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), A national randomized controlled trial of the impact of public Montessori preschool at the end of kindergarten (Lillard et al.), 2025-10-20. Read October 20, 2026.
- What Works Clearinghouse (Institute of Education Sciences), WWC review of Lillard et al. (2025), Study 95226, January 2026. Read October 20, 2026.
- Frontiers in Psychology, Montessori Preschool Elevates and Equalizes Child Outcomes: A Longitudinal Study (Lillard et al.), 2017-10-30. Read October 20, 2026.
- Campbell Systematic Reviews (via PubMed Central), Montessori education's impact on academic and nonacademic outcomes: A systematic review (Randolph et al.), 2023-08-07. Read October 20, 2026.
- Child Care Aware of America, Child Care in America: 2024 Price & Supply. Read October 20, 2026.
- MontessoriPublic (National Center for Montessori in the Public Sector), Building public Montessori together, 2026-06-18. Read October 20, 2026.
- AMI/USA, Choosing a School. Read October 20, 2026.
Keep reading
- How do I know if my child is ready for Montessori preschool?
- How do I do Montessori at home without buying expensive materials?
- Montessori vs traditional preschool: how is the day different?
- What is the Montessori work cycle?